Sunday, October 11, 2009

plx comment

hello everyone!!! pls feel free to comment on my icon and i desperately need it jz nid to noe other ppl thought on my icon so pls drop a comment or write in the cbox k aso ...pls answer the following question
so below tis is my pixel icon











and here is my vector icon








1)what the first theme that u think on ur mind?
a)factory
b)home
c)monster
d)no idea

2)can u recognise both the icon (home and contacts) ?
a)can for both
b)can for vector
c)can for pixel
d)cannot( why?)pls comment ur reason

3)how does the finishing of my vector icon design?
a)well done
b)so-so
c)can be improved
d)weak

4)how does the finishing of my pixel icon design?
a)well done
b)so-so
c)can be improved
d)weak

5)how does the color look to you?
a)impressive
b)so-so
c)can be improved(tips)
d)weak

6)what suggestion,hints and tips that u have to improve my icon design?
(optional)......thank you for ur cooperation!! ^^
Posted by at

5 comments:

  1. Ee KangOctober 11, 2009 at 7:42 AM

    1)a
    2)a
    3)c
    4)c
    5)c
    6)i think both ur vector and icon can improve alot. there are still alot of space for improvement. mayb in term of the design? or colour?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Still ChloeOctober 11, 2009 at 7:50 AM

    1) Monster or... factory. its a bit of both actually
    2) can for both
    3) so-so, not bad.
    4) can be improved
    5) so-so
    6) I like your vector design a lot! It looks quite cool but maybe you can change the color to make it stand out more and more menacing? Also for the pixel icon, maybe you can make it smaller or improve on the color for a smoother effect. But GOOD JOB. Keep it up! :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. UnknownOctober 11, 2009 at 8:17 AM

    1)what the first theme that u think on ur mind?
    a)factory

    2)can u recognise both the icon (home and contacts) ?
    a)can for both

    3)how does the finishing of my vector icon design?
    c)can be improved


    4)how does the finishing of my pixel icon design?
    c)can be improved


    5)how does the color look to you?
    c)can be improved(tips)


    6)what suggestion,hints and tips that u have to improve my icon design?
    i think u have to improve more on your perspective,color combination and also compostition.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Fang LeeOctober 11, 2009 at 8:36 AM

    1)what the first theme that u think on ur mind?
    a)factory and monster

    2)can u recognise both the icon (home and contacts) ?
    a)can for both

    3)how does the finishing of my vector icon design?
    c)can be improved

    4)how does the finishing of my pixel icon design?
    c)can be improved

    5)how does the color look to you?
    c)can be improved(tips)
    - erm, i think u can try on other colours. and, i think ur shadow is a bit weird...

    6)what suggestion,hints and tips that u have to improve my icon design?
    i think the shape can be more round a bit...for me la..i think very shape...n the dhape like weird weird...n the colour aso...the pixel maybe can put more colour is a bit flat....hehe...jia you lo...haha...

    ReplyDelete
  5. kazen_kohOctober 11, 2009 at 9:04 AM

    1)onli factory can close to what i think...lol
    2)can 4 both
    3)can be improve...still got many ways to improve
    4)can b improve
    5)more colour changes and add any more detail colour
    6)perspective abit out liao, can b better... colour combination can try more....

    ReplyDelete

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)